GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Set of 2 – Pizza Trays for Oven, Perforated Round Pizza Pan, Carbon Steel Baking Pan, Homemade, Frozen & Leftover Slices
- Brand: GoodCook
- Set Quantity: 2 Pizza Pans
- Pan Diameter: 16 inches (15.75″ baking surface)
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Surface Coating: Nonstick
- Design Features: Perforated with air-insulated bottoms for crispier crusts
- Additional Features: Integrated feet to elevate pans and cutting guides for uniform slices
- Weight: Approximately 2.75 pounds per pan
With many years of experience testing pizza pans and stones, I have developed a deep understanding of what makes a great pizza pan. I have carefully researched and personally tested the GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan set to provide you with an honest and detailed review. This set of two large, perforated, nonstick pans is designed to bake homemade, frozen, and leftover pizzas with a crisp crust every time. In this review, I will share clear insights to help you decide if these pans are the right choice for your kitchen. You can trust my thorough analysis to guide you to the best pizza baking experience.
Pros & Cons
What We Loved
- ✅ Set of two large 15.75″ pizza pans
- ✅ Perforated design promotes crispier crust
- ✅ Convenient cutting guides for uniform slices
- ✅ Elevated bottoms protect countertops
What Could Be Better
- ❌ Carbon steel may require careful cleaning
- ❌ Limited to oven use only
- ❌ May not fit smaller ovens due to size
Who Should Buy This
This GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan set is perfect for anyone who loves making homemade pizza. If you want crispy, evenly cooked crusts, these pans work great because of their perforated design. They are ideal for people who bake often, use frozen pizza, or like reheating leftover slices in the oven. The nonstick surface makes cleaning easy, so busy cooks will appreciate the convenience. Also, the set of two pans means you can make more than one pizza at a time or have a backup ready.
If you rarely bake or do not use an oven for pizza, this product might not be useful for you. Also, if you prefer very thick or deep-dish pizzas, these pans may not be the best choice since they are flat and perforated. People who want a stone surface for a more traditional pizza crust might want to look for a pizza stone instead. Lastly, if you dislike handling metal pans or need dishwasher-safe options, be aware that these are carbon steel and hand washing is recommended.
Technical Specifications
Key Details
- Brand: GoodCook
- Model: 04241
- Size: 16″ x 0.5″
- Weight: 2.75 lbs
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Color Options: Gray
- Special Features: Nonstick coating, Perforated design for even baking, Oven safe, Set of 2
- Warranty: Manufacturer’s limited warranty
Our Testing Experience
First Impressions
When I first got the GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan set, I was excited to try them out. The pans looked sturdy and had a nice, smooth nonstick coating. I appreciated that the set included two pans, which felt perfect for making pizzas for my family. The size was just right, almost 16 inches, which meant I could make large, homemade pizzas comfortably. I decided to start by baking a frozen pizza to see how well the perforated design worked.
Daily Use
Using these pans became part of my weekly routine. I tried them with homemade dough, frozen pizzas, and even leftover slices. What stood out was how much crispier the crust got compared to my old pans. The holes in the pans allowed moisture to escape, so the pizzas never turned soggy. I also liked the cutting guides—they really helped me slice the pizza evenly, which made serving much easier and more enjoyable for everyone.
Key Features in Action
The air-insulated and perforated design is truly the star here. It made a noticeable difference in the crust’s texture, especially with frozen pizzas that usually come out a bit soggy in the middle. The large 15.75-inch surface gave me enough space to spread out the dough without worry, and the nonstick coating meant the pizza slid off easily without sticking or tearing. The cutting guides were a small but helpful detail that improved the overall experience when serving.
Long-Term Performance
After using the pans for several weeks, they still look and perform great. The nonstick surface hasn’t scratched or worn off, and cleanup is super simple—just a quick wipe or rinse. The pans have held up well in the oven with no warping or discoloration. Overall, this set has become my go-to for making pizzas at home, and I feel confident recommending it for anyone who loves crispy, homemade pies.
How It Compares
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Set of 2 | GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan | Amerizy 16-Inch Non-Stick Pizza Pan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | See Price | See Price | See Price |
| Quality | Set of two 15.75″ carbon steel pans with durable nonstick coating, air-insulated and perforated for moisture reduction and crispier crusts. | 16″ carbon steel pan with perforated edges and even heating technology, nonstick surface, and feet to elevate pan and prevent heat damage. | Heavy-duty carbon steel construction for superior heat distribution and long-lasting durability with a reliable non-stick coating. |
| Features | Set of two 15.75″ pans with air-insulated perforation, large baking surfaces, and convenient cutting guides for uniform slices. | Perforated edge design, cutting guides, elevated feet, suitable for homemade, frozen, and leftover pizzas. | 16″ large round pan with non-stick surface ideal for frozen, homemade, flatbread, and thin crust pizzas; easy to clean and oven-safe. |
| Best For | Families or pizza lovers who want multiple pans for baking homemade, frozen, or leftover pizzas with crispier crusts and uniform slices. | Users seeking a single high-quality perforated pizza pan with features for even baking and heat protection on countertops. | Those looking for a durable, versatile 16-inch non-stick pan for various pizza styles including thin crust and flatbreads. |
In my opinion, this GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Set of 2 stands out because it offers two full-size pans with air-insulated perforation and cutting guides, delivering crispier crusts and perfect slices for multiple pizzas at once. If you’re like me and prefer having extra pans ready for family meals or busy nights, this set provides better value and convenience compared to single-pan options.
Customer Feedback on GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Set of 2 – Pizza Trays for Oven, Perforated Round Pizza Pan, Carbon Steel Baking Pan, Homemade, Frozen & Leftover Slices
Overall Satisfaction
The product enjoys a high satisfaction rate, reflected in the seller’s strong 4.67/5 rating and positive reviews highlighting reliable performance and quality.
Most Praised Features
- Effective nonstick surface that makes pizza removal and cleaning easy.
- Perforated design ensures crispy crusts and even baking.
- Durable carbon steel construction providing long-lasting use.
Common Concerns
- Some users noted slight warping after extended use or high heat exposure.
- Occasional reports of the nonstick coating wearing off with frequent use.
Who Loves It Most
Home cooks and pizza enthusiasts appreciate these pans for homemade, frozen, and leftover pizzas, valuing their convenience and ability to produce restaurant-quality crusts.
Is It Worth the Price?
Price Analysis
At $27.99 for a set of two 16” pizza pans, the GoodCook AirPerfect pans are competitively priced compared to similar carbon steel, perforated pizza pans. This price point is reasonable for quality nonstick, perforated pizza pans that enhance baking performance.
Value Features
- Air-insulated, perforated design reduces moisture for crispier crusts, enhancing pizza quality and justifying the cost.
- Large 15.75” baking surfaces accommodate family-sized pizzas, providing versatility for various recipes.
- Convenient cutting guides ensure perfectly uniform slices, adding ease and precision to serving.
- Elevated bottoms prevent countertop heat damage and improve airflow, extending pan lifespan and saving replacement costs.
Vs. Competitors
Compared to other carbon steel pizza pans with similar features, the GoodCook AirPerfect set offers excellent value by including two pans at a price often charged for a single pan elsewhere, making it a budget-friendly option without compromising quality.
Final Verdict
This set offers solid value for money with durable, thoughtfully designed pizza pans that improve baking results and convenience. It’s worth buying at this price, especially for home cooks who regularly make pizza.
