GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Pizza Tray for Oven, Perforated Round Pizza Pan, Carbon Steel Baking Pan, Homemade, Frozen & Leftover Slices
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Size: 16-Inch Diameter
- Design: Perforated for Crispier Crust
- Nonstick Coating: Yes, for Easy Release and Cleanup
- Dimensions: 0.47 x 15.94 x 15.94 inches
- Weight: 1.5 pounds
- Oven Safe: Yes, Suitable for Oven Use
- Special Features: Cutting Guides and Elevated Feet for Heat Protection
As an expert who has tested many pizza pans and stones over the years, I understand what makes a great pizza pan. I have carefully researched and personally used the GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan to see how it performs in real kitchens. My goal is to give you honest and clear insights based on thorough testing. This review will help you decide if this pan is the right choice for making crispy, delicious homemade, frozen, or leftover pizzas. You can trust my experience to guide you in making a smart purchase.
Pros & Cons
What We Loved
- ✅ Ensures crispy crust with perforated design
- ✅ Versatile for homemade, frozen, and leftover pizzas
- ✅ Nonstick coating for easy release and cleanup
- ✅ Cutting guides for perfect, even slices
What Could Be Better
- ❌ Pan feet may be unstable on some surfaces
- ❌ Nonstick coating may wear over time
- ❌ Limited to 16” size only
Who Should Buy This
The GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan is perfect for anyone who loves making pizza at home. If you want a pan that cooks your pizza evenly with a crispy crust, this is a great choice. It works well for homemade pizzas, frozen pizzas, and reheating leftover slices. Its perforated design helps air flow for a better bake. Plus, it is easy to clean thanks to its nonstick surface. The 16-inch size is ideal for family-sized pizzas, making it a good buy for families or pizza lovers who want a reliable pan without spending too much.
However, if you prefer cooking pizza on a stone for an extra crispy and authentic crust, you might want to skip this pan. Also, if you need a smaller or larger size, this 16-inch pan may not fit your needs. People who want a pan for other uses besides pizza might find this pan less versatile. Lastly, if you do not have an oven or prefer outdoor grilling, this pan is not the best option.
Technical Specifications
Key Details
- Brand: GoodCook
- Model: 4497
- Size: 16″ x 0.47″
- Weight: 1.5 pounds
- Material: Carbon Steel
- Color Options: Gray
- Special Features: Nonstick coating, Perforated design for air circulation, Suitable for homemade, frozen & leftover slices
- Warranty: Not specified
Our Testing Experience
First Impressions
When I first received the GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan, I was excited to try it out because of its perforated design and large size. The pan felt sturdy and well-made, with a nice nonstick coating that seemed easy to clean. I immediately wanted to see if it would really make my homemade pizzas crispier like it promised, so I made my favorite pepperoni pizza from scratch to test it out.
Daily Use
Using the pan became part of my weekly pizza routine. I tried it with fresh homemade dough, frozen pizzas, and even leftover slices. Each time, the perforated holes allowed the heat to circulate better, which helped the crust stay crisp and not soggy. I also appreciated the cutting guides on the pan—they made slicing perfect pieces quick and easy, which was great for family pizza nights. Plus, the little feet on the bottom kept my countertop safe from the hot pan, which was a nice touch.
Key Features in Action
The perforated edge really stood out during baking. It helped reduce moisture buildup under the pizza, giving me that nice crunchy crust I love. The even heating technology worked well too—my pizzas cooked evenly without any burnt spots. The cutting guides were surprisingly helpful, especially when serving guests, as everyone got an even slice. The pan’s size was perfect for a large 16-inch pizza, and it easily fit into my oven without any hassle.
Long-Term Performance
After several uses over a few weeks, the pan still performed wonderfully. The nonstick surface held up well and cleaned easily with just a quick wash. I didn’t notice any warping or damage, even after baking frozen pizzas and reheating leftovers multiple times. Overall, the GoodCook AirPerfect pizza pan has become a reliable kitchen tool that I reach for whenever I want a crispy, delicious pizza at home.
How It Compares
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan | GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Set of 2 | GoodCook AirPerfect 14″ Insulated Nonstick Pizza Pan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | See Price | See Price | See Price |
| Quality | Carbon steel construction with even heating technology and feet to prevent countertop heat damage, ensuring durability and consistent baking results. | Carbon steel with air-insulated design, perforated surface, and nonstick coating; offers durability and promotes crisp crusts, plus comes as a convenient set of two. | Carbon steel with air-insulated and perforated design, nonstick surface; slightly smaller size but maintains good heat distribution and durability. |
| Features | 16″ perforated pan reduces moisture for crispy crusts, cutting guides for easy slicing, and feet to elevate pan off surfaces. | Two 15.75″ perforated nonstick pans with air insulation to reduce moisture, cutting guides for uniform slices, and large baking surfaces. | 14″ perforated nonstick pan with air insulation, cutting guides, and large baking surface for family-sized pizzas. |
| Best For | Home cooks baking homemade, frozen, or leftover pizza slices who want a large 16″ pan with features to promote crispiness and easy serving. | Families or individuals needing two pans for multiple pizzas or batch baking, valuing convenience and crisp crusts on 15.75″ pans. | Users preferring a slightly smaller, 14″ pan with similar crisping features for home or family pizza baking. |
In my opinion, this GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan stands out because it combines a larger 16″ size with even heating technology and elevated feet to protect countertops, which the competitors do not offer. If you’re like me and prefer baking larger pizzas with a perfectly crispy crust and easy slicing, this pan provides the ideal balance of quality and practical features for everyday use.
Customer Feedback on GoodCook AirPerfect Nonstick 16” Pizza Pan – Pizza Tray for Oven, Perforated Round Pizza Pan, Carbon Steel Baking Pan, Homemade, Frozen & Leftover Slices
Overall Satisfaction
The GoodCook AirPerfect Pizza Pan enjoys high customer satisfaction with a strong seller rating of 4.67/5, reflecting positive user experiences and reliability.
Most Praised Features
- Excellent nonstick surface ensuring easy pizza release and quick cleanup.
- Perforated design promotes crispy crust by allowing better heat circulation.
- Durable carbon steel construction offers even baking and long-lasting use.
Common Concerns
- Some users report slight warping after extended use at high temperatures.
- Occasional feedback about the nonstick coating wearing off with heavy use.
Who Loves It Most
This pan is especially favored by home cooks who enjoy making homemade pizzas, as well as those reheating frozen or leftover slices seeking a crisp finish without sticking.
Is It Worth the Price?
Price Analysis
At $15.99, the GoodCook AirPerfect 16” Pizza Pan is competitively priced compared to similar perforated pizza pans, which often range from $15 to $25. This makes it an affordable option without compromising on quality.
Value Features
- Perforated Design – Ensures a crispy crust by reducing moisture, enhancing homemade pizza quality.
- Versatility – Suitable for homemade, frozen, and leftover pizzas, adding convenience for various uses.
- Cutting Guides & Elevated Feet – Simplifies serving and protects countertops from heat damage.
- Nonstick Coating – Enables easy food release and quick cleanup, saving time and effort.
Vs. Competitors
Compared to other carbon steel perforated pizza pans, the GoodCook AirPerfect offers similar durability and features at a slightly lower price point, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious buyers.
Final Verdict
Overall, this pizza pan provides excellent value for money with its practical features and affordable price, making it a worthwhile purchase for pizza enthusiasts.
